The Trouble With Blogging….

When you set out to write a feature like this, there’s a massive temptation to over-share, pour out all your woes and use it as a way to make yourself feel better – or worse, depending upon the outcome!

But, it’s definitely not just me that’s really feeling the strain of blogging – there’s a mood across the blogosphere that you’d probably only sense if you’re either a regular reader of many blogs or you are a blogger yourself.

When you work on-line all the time, mood shifts are common – it’s hard to explain – but you can just feel it and chances are, if you’re feeling it, everyone else is too.

So rather than just a woe-is-me post, I’m trying to really understand what’s caused it. Most of the bloggers I know work really, really hard – it might look all glitz and glam but often the reality is very different. And that’s a key part of the problem – there is no switch off. You need to be a very confident blogger indeed to decide that you can’t really be bothered to post for a few days.

PRs are in despair at how to get key bloggers to go to launches – their clients set the bars far too high in expectation thinking they can cherry pick their desired guest list and bloggers will come running. It’s almost impossible for many reasons – one of which is that we’re at overload. Not a day passes when someone doesn’t want something from you. I have one or two PR friends that I’d consider actual friends – that I see ‘out of school’ so to speak, but on the whole the subtext to any meeting, event or conversation is that they want something. The upshot of pretend friends is that you end up trusting nobody – and I never used to be this person! When I worked in print, it didn’t feel like this, although as many an ex-editor has discovered, your ‘friends’ flee when your job title disappears.

Instead of launches being exciting and fun, I find them difficult. I’m neither fish nor fowl at press events or blog events. I used to find blog events invigorating; especially watching younger bloggers starting their blog journeys because enthusiasm and excitement is always contagious, but now I feel as though I can’t find my place. I’m an older blogger compared to the average and while blogging should be a leveller (because beauty is one of the greatest of all levellers) I feel that maybe I’m actually too much older for this. I’m very well aware that a lot of commercial opportunities pass me by because of my (older) face and that’s quite disconcerting to be on the receiving end of.. or not, as it is!

Bloggers naturally split into groups – partially, the cause of this is whether you’re with an agency or not. Bloggers at the same agencies tend to support each other only which means if you’re not part of that particular group, it can feel that you are being excluded. I have had nominal agent representation but have never been part of a commercial agency, which means that I set my own worth. And, when you constantly have to assess your own worth, more often than not you estimate you are worth less than you think. I don’t know if that’s part of being a self-deprecating Brit but it’s easier, I think, if someone else decides. I think many bloggers, quite naturally, feel happier and more supported if they’re part of a key friendship group within the community. However, I’ve seen some horrible bullying and exclusion as a result of that – it can be like being back at school. Not all bloggers get along – and that’s a completely normal, natural part of any industry, but because it’s all played out in subtext across social media, there really is no getting away from it. From being a very happy bunch of people all on the same journey, commercialisation has changed it to a group where everyone’s after a slice of the pie.

When it comes to what I transmit to readers – that’s my perfect comfort zone. I know that, to my bones, I’m doing my best to talk about beauty in real terms, to undo the PR and get to the reality of a product, to be a bridge between brand and consumer and to ensure that nobody throws good money on bad product. I’m not the selfie generation – I find it incomprehensible that anyone would want to know what I’m wearing today but that also means a quiet confidence that because I’m not the face of, er, me, so to speak, I can go about my business without having to worry what anyone else thinks of my shoes.

There’s a general shift in the industry regarding YouTube – a kind of lethargy, I think you might say. The only place that I’m seeing any kind of real buzz is Instagram still and an early buzz about Periscope, which I think digital industry insiders are tipping to outstrip – eventually – YT. Brands, PRs, influencers are all starting to yearn for the next big thing, whatever that might be.

I think it might be a question of digital fatigue, both for those of us putting it out there and those consuming it. Losing your blogging mojo has always been a thing, but this time it’s for very different reasons.

On the absolute up, I love reading comments from readers and interaction in general; that’s the thing for most bloggers and anyone in the digital space that keeps us going! I have readers that have been with me for years; sometimes I’m lucky enough to meet them in real life and that’s always an absolute delight (except when they hug me ;-)) to have these relationships. Despite the fact they’re on-line, they’re very real to me. I don’t write for brands or for PRs (sponsored posts aside, and always clearly labelled) – I’m writing to, and for, people just like me.

I don’t know what the future holds – whether blogging will be more enduring than YouTube or Snapchat or Periscope, Meerkat, Instagram, Pinterest, Vine or any of the other millions of social channels. All I know is that a lot of us feel uncertainty about our place.

 


Discover more from British Beauty Blogger

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Have your say

84 responses to “The Trouble With Blogging….”

  1. It’s interesting to read this, and a bit disheartening, if I’m honest.
    Yours is my ‘reference blog’ for beauty news, like Caroline Hirons is my reference for skincare. I’m 50 next year and I’m a sophisticated online audience – I don’t trust much that I read online and I can smell PR hooey from a mile off. In fact, PR hooey is what made me stop trusting print magazines’ beauty reviews.

    It has taken me a while to distill my online reading down to a select few blogs that I trust to be unbiased or at least open about their bias, but yours is one I read every day. Heck, I even read Sali Hughes online rather than in the actual newspaper.

    And by the way, I really like to READ about products and brands and what is coming up, rather than watching videos or using an app on my phone. The only time I want to see a video is when it’s Lisa Eldridge or Mary Greenwell showing me how to do a particular make up look. But I prefer to read Lisa’s reviews of products.

    Please keep going; and I hope the PRs actually realise your value. I would take one good blog like yours over a dozen Zoellas.

    1. Jane

      Thank you Lisa for your kind comments. I think the PRs are under pressure for a quick fix – there are many who are as supportive as they can be of what bloggers do, but often their hands are tied by client expectations. Some clients are almost deluded in their thinking around bloggers, demanding Pixiwoo or similar to appear. If they don’t.. the PR gets it in the neck. So, the pressure increases in the chain, landing squarely on us at the end of it!

    2. Caroline

      Very well said Lisa. I feel exactly the same way, and my online habits are the same as yours too (I’m 45).

  2. Sam

    You know, I think part of the problem is that the blogosphere is an unregulated industry.

    Where there are no barriers to entry, no standards, no rules against which each blogger can measure his/herself, there is basically chaos. If bloggers don’t set the rules, then PRs and brands will do the directing.

    You have from the top of the supply chain, like yourself, all the way down to the bottom where young girls “blog” in order to get free product. If they don’t get invited to events, or don’t get given free product, they slate off the brand online. It is no wonder that PR companies and brands are trying to reign in bloggers and control what is put out there.

    And they do. They acquire sponsored posts and endorsements, even bloggers becoming celebrities and completely ‘owned’ by a brand. If that is the supply, is there any wonder there is a demand for more of the same?

    The other day on Twitter I saw a comment by a relatively respected and mature blogger, saying:

    @brandname thank you for unfollowing me. Surprised but reciprocated the gesture.

    It was so unnecessary. So petty. And smaller brands might feel held to ransom by comments like that. Imagine what she would write if she hadn’t been invited to an event?! I promptly unfollowed her & I think others have done the same.

    You say that PRs are in despair at how to get bloggers to attend events but I am seeing the tide turning. A well-known, international skincare brand whose founder I know, will not deal with bloggers anymore. No free product, no event invites, no press releases, no followings on Instagram or Twitter. Positive comments (from anybody) receive ‘thank you’s’ and complaints are responded to quickly and efficiently.

    I can see your frustration. Perhaps there is an opportunity here to create a ‘standard’, an association, have your own awards ceremony each year like CEW where you award prizes to the best brand (in different categories) and PR agency etc.

    The ‘standard’ would create a set of values to which member bloggers would adhere, and values for brands and agencies that would help direct the activities of your community/industry.

    Like other associations, you’d be able to assess and pre-empt threats to your business model (UBER vs the Black Cab industry) and turn them into opportunities.

    Dunno… just an idea…

    1. Jane

      Thank you for such an insightful blogger – some unfollows are real stingers though so I kind of empathise there even though I can see to the viewer or reader it looks unprofessional. And just as unprofessional of the brand to unfollow when there’s now a mute option (that I use often) that causes no harm or offence. I think talk of a ‘standard’ has been around since blogging began and has been attempted but for very commercial blogs, it just doesn’t work, and again I think may cause further division – those in and those out. I can also understand brands just getting tired of the whole digital thing, but in my view, it’s a mistake to punish all because of one or two. And in the long run, if a brand gets no on-line coverage, it’s at a disadvantage. There is kind of a perception of bloggers (and I’d just like to point out that I don’t see myself at the top – it never feels that way, anyway) that they’re greedy and grabby but in the majority of cases, I don’t really see that, and for bloggers like me, it’s sad that is the perception.

      1. Sam

        Well, I’d disagree with the ‘at the top comment’. You have my enormous respect and support and my opinion of most bloggers out there is pretty blah!! So you are certainly at the top of MY supply chain.

        In all honesty I can understand that brand not wanting to be associated with the blogger I mentioned. Some of her comments to anyone that proffers an alternative view are acerbic and defensive. One minute she gushes over a brand, the next she cuts them off over something as small as a Twitter unfollow. It’s just schoolgirl silliness. Having culled her own following, she was rather calling the kettle black.

        And if I were a brand, I’d be very careful about who I’d follow. It suggests a relationship that may be in direct contradiction to the brand image. So I would actually argue that it is professional of a brand to associate with the ‘right’ followers.

        The point you make about the digital world exposure is very valid. But this is where the problem lies – digital innovation. Bloggers came before Twitter, Instagram and all the other new techs. Print, websites and blogging were really the only avenues. Oh yes, and Facebook. But a brand can connect directly on so many more ways now… again, I think that this disruptive technology may in part play a problem…

        Suffice to say hang in there. Take a break every so often and re-energise. Your integrity, transparency and honesty are heartwarming and more than refreshing. They are your brand.

        1. Jane

          Amazing to hear your viewpoint – actually so helpful for me to see my way through and I’m very happy to be top of your list! I agree regarding brands being maybe more choosy about how and who they work with; we definitely have a top tier that are losing their appeal through over-use. But, marketing departments are run usually by young people who are looking at numbers not even relevance, never mind content and you just can’t beat that system. You can’t. I am doing my bit by speaking to brands about all kinds of different bloggers – younger and older – and about how their approach is so key, but there are some.. you can tell them nothing! They are awed by numbers and that’s all.

  3. eve

    I have nothing to do with blogging(apart from reading them!)and yet I sense there is a general exhaustion in the air. Everyone is blogging about the same products, it’s getting harder to be impartial and the younger bloggers/vloggers are under so much pressure to pimp out their lives I kind of feel sorry for them. I reckon that in the next year or two, there will be a lot of blogs/bloggers falling by the wayside. I read your blog Jane because it is simply my favourite, I read caroline hirons because of her excellent knowledge that she loves to pass on, and buy now blog later simply because Laura blogs when she likes and has no agenda. Every thing is getting very samey and dare I say it BORING! I think that in order to survive bloggers will have to have a rethink and stop simply being a mouthpiece for brands. If I see one more review for the body shop I think I will scream!!

    1. Jane

      To be honest, the money is in being a mouthpiece. That’s what I mean about commercialisation. Thanks for dropping in though.. I might, er, have a Body Shop post coming up… you might need to look away soon… 😉

    2. Jane

      I’m so sorry. … missed the bit about this being your favourite blog.. that’s so kind..thank you so much!

  4. Alice

    This was interesting to read! I don’t have a big audience yet so cannot empathise with this but can definitely sympathise! It must be disheartening but just remember you know more than the younger ones and have more experience and probably, talent 🙂 xx
    alicekatex ♥

  5. Aine

    I have a small blog too and I’ve been feeling a bit samey recently. I’ve been a bit aghast over the last year seeing a flood of bloggers promoting a brand/product all at once, I often end up distrusting the product until I see a proper review on it either by yourself or others of a similar ilk. Don’t give up, you’re one of a handful of bloggers that I trust. I have based myself on you ladies, I’m always honest. I know it’s important to make a living with sponsors etc, but it’s odd when I see some people raving about a product & then people purchase said item and it turns out to be rather shit! I’m slowing down how often I post on my blog/YT and I’m trying to really focus more on stuff I want to read, rather than keeping up with the latest “it” thing. I don’t connect with younger bloggers at all any more, I’m only 33 and I think there should be more of us over the 20 something age group. We don’t suddenly stop purchasing products when we pass 25! In fact I spend more now than I ever did in my 20s. I always tend to stick to my peers and use them as a reference point when investigating a product. I don’t know, maybe I’m just weary but it’s all a bit weird at the minute. I have noticed that I did fall into a weird way of being, I was much less myself and I was trying to keep up with the Jones. I’m getting back to myself and I’m slowly moving away from the main stream I guess. Either way, please stay, take a break if you need, we will be here, look after yourself. You’re a blogger that my mam and I read, we often chat about your posts, we trust you.

    1. Jane

      Thanks so much – I’m so pleased both you and your mum read my blog – that’s great to know. Part of the problem is that it’s a PR’s job to get maximum coverage for their brand. Everything is massively planned ahead so sometimes there is no getting round the ‘all of us at once’ problem, depending upon how controlling the agency or the brand wants to be. I spend a lot of time trying to get exclusives for BBB readers but nowadays, brands, needing to be in control at all times, often do their own across their own channels. But thank you again.. I am honestly grateful for your trust.

      1. Caroline

        Hi Jane

        Just a very quick bit of feedback – I do enjoy your exclusives but what I enjoy more is your honest, unbiased opinion. The product you’re reviewing may be something that I’ve seen featured somewhere else earlier, but I will always read your post too because you’re the person I trust the most!

        1. Jane

          thank you ..that’s really good to know!

  6. Really enjoyed reading this on my second blogging birthday Jane! I totally agree that there seems to be a funny ‘feeling’ in the air at the moment. Personally I am carrying on as I always have done doing this as a hobby and have actually decided not to even attempt to make it any kind of career because it seems when it has become a career, things get commercialised and it’s incredibly hard to remain true to yourself. It really does seem a case of digital fatigue all round, but that means something new is on the way and it’s a case of riding out the storm to see what that is. I would be happy to go on reading your blog forever though and it’s important that you know that.
    Thanks again for a hugely interesting post. I have so little experience compared to yourself and find you an inspiration Jane, so well done on that, and I hope you are feeling better seeing how many people have the utmost respect for you and whatever form of blogging you choose to take!
    Rebecca | http://www.forevertwotwentysomethings.com
    Xx

    1. Jane

      Rebecca, that’s so nice to know.. thank you for taking the time x

  7. lanina

    Dear Jane

    Your blog is amazing, through you I have discovered many great beauty products that I otherwise may never have found. I understand the frustration and I used to love reading several blogs, but many of the “newer” ones fail to inspire. I am in my late twenties, and never felt that you are old, your reviews are spot on and I appreciate your honesty. I have come to detest the “hype” of certain products and enjoy getting a real opinion.

    Yours is the only beauty blog I still follow and that ever gets me to even consider a new product (I am reaching the phase of less better products). Plus living in a country that is very conservative and expensive for beauty products, I find a lot of inspiration.

    So long story short, keep doing what you are doing, if PR’s and brands fail to understand that what makes you great is being honest and real, it is their loss. If they would like products to be hyped and great, they should make great products that you can work with. Good for you for seeing through all the marketing blah and giving readers an honest opinion. In todays world brands should begin to understand the consumer is well informed, will not believe everything and would like a second opinion. If they can not live up to those standards, they should do some work on their products, instead of constantly aiming to screw consumers around. The days of the desperate housewives who believe everything on TV are over – if a product is great, prove it. When you say something is worth having a look at, I can count on it.

    So keep it up Jane, don’t let the business side wear you down, there will always be people who look down at you, see it as a sign of success. Your age does not matter for a single second – I have been following your blog for years and can tell you that it truly never mattered. I have always felt that you have a unique and authentic perspective and a fun way of sharing.

    This comment became far longer than planned, sorry about that. Take care and chin up, you deserve to be the great online presence that you are.

    1. Jane

      You’re really kind.. thank you so much for all your words xx

  8. Amazing article Jane. You write so eloquently. I guess from my (albeit limited) perspective, there are so many blogs out there and everyone is doing a YT video (myself included) nowadays to try and grow their own brand and readers maybe are getting a bit bored of it. YT videos now feel like a full on production where you have to get every element perfect, which is why Periscope is such a welcome change. Its raw, it’s live and it’s undone, even though when it first came out my instant reaction was ‘not another bloody thing I’ve got to think about’.

    What I have seen from CEW talks and other events I’ve attended, is a shift towards yearning for a blogger that isn’t 20 anymore because people want someone they can relate to, they trust and who actually knows what they are talking about and this is you. I think maybe you’re just so on the ball with beauty blogging, that most of the industry hasn’t had a chance to catch up yet!

    There is a shift happening and there is uncertainty, but there will always be a place for an educated, real and informed opinion to help women make the right choices in beauty. And I’m sure BBB will always be that place. 🙂

    1. Jane

      Such a lovely comment, and I thank you for it. I can’t complain that I don’t get enough attention from brands because on the whole, I really do, but it feels heavy at the moment and just as though I don’t quite fit anywhere which just ends up feeling isolating and odd. But I’m greatly cheered by all the amazing comments (typically I was expecting negative comments for some reason… I should know how nice my readers are by now), yours included xx

  9. I completely agree with Aine. I’m in my 30s, too, and I’m so tired of cutesy little 17 year old bloggers reviewing anti-aging eye serums! I just don’t relate to them. I have been blogging on and off for about 5 years in Dubai and the PR-Blogger relationships here are pretty messed up as well. Lot of the bloggers that are ‘popular’ here nowadays have tens of thousands of Instagram followers, but surprise! Almost no blog views (or sometimes they don’t even have a blog). I never felt like I fit into the blogging scene, and it made me stop for a while, but I’m back and just doing whatever I want to do (and loving it!) I’m not sure if I will ever make money doing this, but I guess that doesn’t matter anymore.

    Anyway, without sounding dramatic, I think there are always going to be people who want honest reviews that make sense and that’s exactly what you do. I think the world would be such a sad, sad place if people like you gave up. There wouldn’t be the variety that makes the internet so special. I get disheartened sometimes too, but hopefully all of the other comments have shown how important you really are to the world of blogging. You really are in a completely different ballpark, and that’s why we love you!

    1. Jane

      Thank you so much Aseya! That’s so lovely of you. I guess when change is about to happen, everyone gets kind of jumpy… we just don’t really know what the changes are going to be, only that there is an attitude shift. There’s a lot of very, very tired bloggers out there! *jumps into bed* xx

  10. How weird you should write a post about this. I don’t blog but I read many, but just recently, I’ve been getting blog-weary vibes from many bloggers and vloggers. I’m seeing a veer away from beauty chat to other topics. Is this boredom, or a sign of getting fed up with the same old, same old? You are without doubt, in my view, the best, and if someone was standing over me with a gun telling me I had to choose just one blogger to read, it would be you. Your posts are always informative, well written, but what singles you out is that they’re always fresh.
    I’m wondering whether maturity has something to do with it? It’s the younger bloggers I’m getting these apathetic vibes from. Blogging isn’t something you train in, but the blogosphere is so vast, some may have reached an impasse and need help and guidance to ‘progress’. I do think the blog market is getting close to saturation. But I don’t see where it’s going to give.

    1. Jane

      some good points Cathy and lovely compliments too, which I thank you for (*fetches gun*)! okay well I think it’s partially that the brands are taking back control so we aren’t as ‘free to roam’ as we used be, it’s partially that when you are one of few (older in this case), you just don’t fit in as you did, and you’re right.. we’re at saturation point – whether that’s a digital saturation, a blog saturation or just over peeping into the lives of others, I’m not sure.

  11. bonniegarner

    Jane it’s unbelievable the number of times I read your posts and feel like you have been reading my mind lately 😉
    You would not believe how much I can relate to your post. I feel like the odd one out. I also attend events (less than I’d like, OK maybe I’d like to select a few I’m really interested in) but never really feel like I can even get what I want out them in 80% of the cases.
    Having worked in the beauty industry for years, I’ve been on the other side training people how to use products, advising people which products to buy and just straight forward selling.

    Too often I feel like I can’t get what I need from events, sometimes I don’t even get a product to test, sometimes I don’t get any straight answers to my questions and then as you say I’ll get hounded by the company or PR agency to write a good review. I even once had a PR person ask me why I hadn’t written a piece about a serum 1 week after the event: as if you can test a serum and see the results about it in 1 week. #facepalm

    But to join in with some previous comments, and after reading your post, I must admit I now feel depressed because you are on of a very few reference blogs/people that I admire and thoroughly enjoy reading. But, yes, you’re right, I feel that the blogging situation is quite difficult at the moment.
    Hey the truth is not always easy to hear, or maybe I just don’t want to hear it 😉

    My hope is that all this “instant, now, now, now” trend will give way to a recognition of quality content and advice so that you (and I would like to think I) can be recognized for what we bring to the table.
    I certainly will continue to read you, so please continue to write your though provoking and insightful posts for a long time (I don’t mind if you take a few days break between articles btw 😉 )

    1. Jane

      Thank you Bonnie..really kind of you.. this is what’s weird.. it’s kind of a collective feeling that’s going on. PRs would very much miss us if we weren’t here and so would brands! I think a break is over-due to be honest..part of the problem, but I can’t swan off for a week knowing my stats will drop when I have advertisers who have expectations (one way to minimise the amount of sponsored posts).. so it’s difficult. And yet, getting a week’s worth of posts together is a gigantic task… I’m desperate to go to Japan actually..so maybe I’ll take no ads for that month and then I can just go! eek… the possibilities.

      1. bonniegarner

        Jane, you definitely have to go to Japan! You deserve it! (and I can’t wait to read the reviews you’ll write about the incredible Japanese cosmetics you’ll find there ah ah ah)

        1. Jane

          I am desperate to go.. I think one of the writers at The Women’s Room has just been so I’m going to ask her for some tips.

          1. bonniegarner

            My friend Aseya (who commented below) is half Japonese. I’m sure she can give you some tips as well! 😉

          2. Jane

            oh super! thankyou x

  12. Georgie

    I also agree about the blogging lethargy, a very timely article!!! I was about to start a new blog (I had one years ago) and I’ve been working really, really hard researching,writing/gathering articles, taking pics etc…. And just recently I’ve felt like it would be pointless, more like a gut feeling/female intutition?? (It was either that or hormones!) That and a lot of the blogs I used to follow have really gone down hill in terms of the content – both quantity and quality. To be honest, it’s this decline that led me to believe there was a gap in the market. A couple of the bloggers I used to follow, who used to be quite successful, have just stopped with no explanation… As a reader, I’ve been noticing this as a pattern across the US, UK, Australia and Ireland. I have to say that I am not particularly interested in what I call the more “voyeuristic” lifestyle/beauty blogs/vlogs but I know that is not the “norm” and I think that is probably because I am older as well. It occurred to me that the older bloggers were becoming increasingly preoccupied with their other jobs and family lives and the younger bloggers all seemed too vacuous. I’ve been thinking a lot of Terry Gilliam’s Brazil recently …. However I LOVE this blog, it’s one of the only good ones!!! Don’t lose heart!!

    1. Jane

      Thank you..that’s so kind. I think there is natural shedding with blogs.. people move on and their lives change focus. I would support your idea of a blog if you’ve already put the work in, and always bear in mind that there WILL be people who want to read it – but keep your benchmark for readership realistic at first. Blogs really do take time to evolve and believe it or not, I still see new (ish) blogs breaking through x

  13. Lisa

    I really like our blog and one of the things I like most is that you are an older blogger and not naive about the industry or yourself. The blogoshere is full of 20 somethings reviewing eye serum and saying they need full coverage foundation – err no! It’s refreshing to see someone who is older, addressing issues of older women and who knows (and will tell us) what’s going on behind the scenes with brands.

    Readers I think appreciate you need to earn money but having just read what I thought was a review of product I was interested in, only to find the words ‘sponsored post’ in small print at the bottom it annoys me when bloggers don’t treat their audience with respect.

    Finally I also think video is overrated, maybe for an older audience – I just want to read the facts! (I also want the science and the politics – not just ‘it smells lovely’, I’m 40 and that’s not doing it for my skin anymore) I don’t have a quiet place in my house to watch videos by myself so unless it’s something in particular like a Lisa Eldridge look, I’m not going to bother. We aren’t teenagers in our bedrooms and we have far more spending power than them so please beauty industry, wise up!

    1. Lisa

      Aaargh – mispelled first sentence – YOUR blog, obviously!!!!!!

    2. Jane

      Thank you for your words.. very wise.. I really hope that brands will finally start to get that they need to be less awed by numbers and more respectful to their target audience. With sponsored posts, unless it’s information only, products are truly tested and given the same criteria as non sponsored, the difference being that the brand gets a guaranteed post. If the product is awful, the sponsored post just doesn’t happen. I’ve spent 8 years building my reputation – I’m not going to lose it over a misguided sponsored post.

  14. Nazneen

    lovely post jane, I read a handful of blogs, and I can definitely see a PR marketing thing going on when the same products keep reappearing.. and its like here we go again. I like reading blogs on skincare as a means of discovering new products, but it really frustrates me when I see these young beautiful bloggers rave about an anti ageing skincare product,.I mean does a 20 year old something really need to use a product with a derivative of vitamin A????? I keep seeing reviews of Luna popping up. I know Luna is good, but surely it would be more beneficial to women with older skin. i know its good to start using vitamin A.quite early on, but Luna is £85.00!!!
    I love reading your blog and miss your videos. you just make me laugh in a good way.

    1. Jane

      ah thank you so much.. recording more videos with Simon on Friday!

  15. Eva

    Dear Jane,

    I don’t have anything super insightful to say, but I just wanted to say I’m sorry you’re finding blogging more difficult and wearing and that I’m so glad you do what you do!

    I don’t read many blogs anymore, largely because I feel like since so many beauty bloggers and youtubers have signed with agencies it’s all become too commercial and samey. I’m so fed up of seeing the same things being said about the same products wherever I look and never knowing if it’s because they’re good or if it’s because that particular brand has made a deal with a big agency. I think it’s great finding out about new launches and things in advance now brands work with bloggers and I love a good swatch post, but I find myself taking most bloggers opinions with a large pinch of salt or I give up reading them altogether.

    But I check your blog nearly everyday. I’ve been a blog reader for years and your blog and Laura’s (lollipoo26/buy now blog later) are the two that have stood the test of time for me. I love that I never have to ask myself if you’re only writing about something because you’re getting paid or given free products, because with you I feel I can trust I’m getting an honest opinion in every post. I love that you give an inside view on blogging with no sugar coating and that I can always find an interesting post about so many different things relating to beauty not just ‘here’s a bunch of new stuff I love it all now go buy it’.

    Sorry this has ended up so long!

    1. Jane

      Thank you so much.. one of the reasons we’re all blogging the same things at the same time is because it’s released to us at the same time.. you’d probably find that those very products all appear in the – let’s say – August issue of all the magazines. Brands like to stay in control. But thank you hugely for sticking with me.. it’s so appreciated x

  16. This post is so honest and sad. It’s so sad to see people who have gone a bit mad over blogging, it should be enjoyable to write just as much as it is to read.

    I started blogging a few months ago when I became upset by just how many sponsored posts there are out there, I wonder would they have even bothered with the product if they hadn’t been sent it? Did they genuinely love it or actually want to review it? Would they have seen it in a store and bought it with their own earned money?

    I love the fact that my blog is mine, there is no pressure to blog everyday, or stick to a specific style or jump onto any bandwagons. The things I put on there are genuine, things I’m passionate about, things I have saved up for because I have loved them. It’s why I won’t say I love a product until it’s near enough empty. I wouldn’t ever see blogging as a job, because the minute you do you stop caring about what you are saying, and care about views, comments, clicks, sponsors.. All the factors that come back round to money. It’s why I love older bloggers, who are over it all, and don’t care if they offend a company by saying they dislike a product or say it’s overpriced. Or brand new bloggers who are just excited and honest.

    I love the blogging world, but it’s a love of mine, not a career or lifestyle, I do it because I enjoy it, and I will stop the minute I become bored or done with it all. That being said I love your blog, I love your honesty. Don’t let it bring you down, look at what actually matters, the people reading who love you for you. They are loyal and they are your friends.

    All my love! MakeErinOver

    1. Jane

      Thank you Erin so much x

  17. Mrs Tubbs

    Brands and PRs are missing a trick. They use older models in advertising to appeal to the largest, wealthy makeup buying demographic. (Me. Over here! Forty something makeup lover with disposable income. Hello …!). But that demographic is not very well represented in the blogosphere. They should be cultivating the likes of you because women tend to listen to the opinions of their peers. A 20 year something is not my peer and looks ridiculous attempting to push high end anti ageing products. It’s like PRs assume we’re not on the Internet. Or if we are, we’re stupid … *rolls eyes*

    You, LBQ, Hirons and My Lady Stuff are the only blogs I I read religiously. If a passing PR is reading, if you’re targeting my demographic, then you need to be online where I am.

    1. Thank you, from LBQ btw! I’m glad that Jane and I are doing something right ; ) xx

  18. thanks for such an insightful post. When I attended my first blogger event I did feel a bit left out by younger bloggers (and made to feel a bit uncomfortable). But luckily I did know one of the small business owners there and met another who was just launching her product.

    1. Jane

      I think it’s me having a confidence dip to be honest.. I’m just realising that I’m not happy in crowds any more.

  19. As a reader of blogs I have definitely noticed a change recently, there seems to be way to many bloggers who just seem to be in it for free stuff, which is taking my interest away from their blogs. I am 36 years old and am fed up of reading some bloggers whinge because they didn’t get as good products as some got. They should be greatful for what they get. I look to your blog as one where I can find an honest review and I know that you are not afraid to speak your mind, which I think is sadly lacking in other blogs. It is all getting a bit to much like school to me where one person is trying to out do another.
    I hope you don’t decide to give up on your blog because I for one would be very disappointed as I am sure everybody else who reads your posts would be to. Like many others have said there needs to be many more older bloggers out there because we need reviews from people who the products are actually aimed at and not from people who are barely out of school. I’m sorry for the long winded comment.

    1. Jane

      I appreciate the long comment! Thank you so much for your thoughts. I think that younger bloggers greatly appeal to their own demographic, so they definitely have their place in the blogosphere, but one thing I do notice is that younger women will read blogs from all age groups and older readers are less inclined to that, preferring to find blogs from women nearer their own age. It’s something I hadn’t though of until I’ve had so many positive and encouraging comments on this post. x

      1. Cy

        I second that, hell I’m even reading this ManFace blog and I’m definitely not a man! 😉

  20. Trimperley

    It’s not just a mood across the blogosphere I think the whole country is in a mood and I don’t see things settling down until after the Budget. The Government should have announced its budget earlier.

    One of the “joys” of being self employed is that you can never quite let go for a break. You must fight this or you will make yourself ill. Most punters will accept that you need a holiday from time to time. At the very least always take a holiday in August when everyone else is away. The work/blog will still be there when you get back.

    I greatly enjoy your blog. I much prefer text and photos to videos. Would a weekly/monthly neutral diary style piece of launches I did not attend/did attend appease the prs?

    “commercial opportunities pass me by because of my (older) face and that’s quite disconcerting to be on the receiving end of” name and shame the buggers

    1. Jane

      That’s a wise point.. I think you are right that there is a general air of despondency, and thank you so much for your comments. The whole older face thing is there, but nobody ever says it directly otherwise I might be greatly tempted to name! I have had comments like ‘well, the marketing team are looking to speak to young women’… as if younger women don’t read this blog. I have readers of all ages. Beauty is ageless – you can be 20 or 90 and still extract the same pleasure from a gorgeous lipstick, but try telling a marketing man that! Anyway, I am onwards and upwards.. and thank you again x

  21. Clbnolan

    I realise I’m bring totally selfish here, but feel like I need to say ‘Don’t stop writing the blog Jane!!’
    I look to your blog for clear beauty reviews that I genuinely trust to be truthful. I don’t really care to know what your Outfit Of The Day is or other crap like that. I want the opinion of someone who has access to & uses the best beauty stuff out there, so that when they say a product is great, I really believe it.
    I LOVE the fact that you’re my age bracket – that’s a really important factor with some product. Why would I believe an great looking 20 year old who raves about how great her skin looks after using a £150 serum? How bad can it look when you’re a super cute 20 year old? It’s like testing oven cleaner on a new oven!
    As far as I’m concerned, you’re relevant, you’re intelligent & you’re honest. You’re videos with Simon are also pure joy!
    I love that you post daily but if I had the choice of no BBB or just a weekly BBB post, I would gladly wait all week for a post worth reading!

    1. Jane

      Thank you so much for the encouragement – I am ploughing on! I think though that Trimperley’s comment is true – everyone is feeling, oh I guess you would say in the doldrums. This has resonated with so many people feeling the same, whether blogger or not, that I think I know now it’s not just me!

  22. Don’t stop Jane. I read you every day. I really look forward to your posts, far more than any other blogs. Seriously.

    1. Jane

      Thank you so much Sue x

  23. the40somethingbeautyaddict

    This is my favourite blog! Your feisty, honest and witty and I respect you for your straight down the line honesty on products no matter what. As for age it is only a number and being 46 myself I will never let it stop me enjoying my beauty products or blogging about them. There is a whole world of older women out there backing you and loving what you do even if it is in the face of the dark side of the beauty world … respect!!

    1. Jane

      and back at you! thank you so much for all your support. x

      1. the40somethingbeautyaddict

        So welcome x

  24. Keala Jewell

    Very interesting when you write about the nitty gritty side. Pressure is hard to manage. You’ve been very even about what are difficult work problems. Your blog comes into my junk mail folder for some reason, but I quickly blot out everything in there and open yours every morning. I just love your blog.It’s just the right length daily. You should get paid for therapy! You are very stylish! Your writing is so accomplished! You are my top blogger! Thank you.

    1. Jane

      thank you so much Keala! sorry that I’m landing in your junk mail though..that’s not good!

  25. Hi Jane,
    Wow! As someone who is a relatively new beauty brand owner, with a background as far away from the beauty industry as it is probably possible to be (I’m a middle aged man, geek and beekeeper), your blog is always interesting and unlike so many others, you actually HAVE A VOICE!

    We work with our marketing and PR teams (I’m in awe of their work load and ability to deliver) to engage with many bloggers on a daily basis and I can’t tell you how disappointing it is to read exactly the same words cut and pasted from our own website time and time again. I know there is a fine line to stay “on brand”, but sometimes, just sometimes, I’d love a blogger to just ring me up or email me with a few questions so we can chat about our ethos and why we think we can make a difference.

    That’s why I love going out to blogger events and meeting so many amazing looking women with the high end cameras round their necks. It’s almost like you can judge their seriousness by their photography budget… But, the great thing is that we end up chatting beauty, bees or both and we all come away learning something from each other. Several new product ideas have come from those conversations and I really treasure engaging with those that represent my potential end customers.

    Age doesn’t really come into it from my point of view, it’s the level of commitment and passion that matters to me. We seem to give away a scary volume of our products for free which hurts when I think of the budgets involved and its even more depressing when you see the same products you worked so hard for appear on eBay at knock-down prices…

    But, every day I read your blog, and whilst I don’t understand all that you are talking about, I really respect your authority, expertise and real opinions, good or bad! I only wish that more bloggers and PR companies realised how important being authentic really is to everyone from the brand through to the consumer. Yes, there is a vast amount of candy-floss fluff, and PR guff around, and yes, I do sometimes think that the whole blogosphere is like a conveyor belt with a constant stream of bright new writers either dropping out or becoming dull PR regurgitators. But there are quite a few bloggers who speak from the heart and who’s writing is actually honest and engaging enough for the audience to stick with them and it’s no coincidence that your blog has become required reading for everyone with an interest in the beauty industry…

    1. Jane

      Simon, thank you for all your kind comments and it’s especially interesting to hear from a brand. So far, you’re the only one, so I think we know which way the good bees fly! xx

      1. The only brand, crazy isn’t it. Love BeeGood btw Simon 🙂

  26. Hi Jane,

    Tremendous discussion. Like other comments, I agree the timing of your post is spot on.
    I have been following the beauty blogosphere since 2007 when my sister and I launched e.l.f. cosmetics to the UK and Europe. We experienced some real glory years when the space first started to explode. I am very grateful to the bloggers we worked with as the helped us build the brand. We formed great relationships with Bloggers and Customers on social networks. (Facebook was a different beast back then when you could actually reach and communicate with followers without paying.

    As the space has grown and the various social channels have “developed” we have seen a shift from communication to advertising in all it’s forms. (sponsored posts, banners, video ads etc). The boiling pot is just getting bigger and bigger and it seems to be the case these days that the biggest richest brands have found a way (yet again) to bully their way to the top of the pot.

    I read a comment about the shift in Power is moving back to the brands and that is something that resonates with me. In the communication revolution the power should always be with the consumer. The power shift is because rich companies are throwing money about and I question if any of them really care about customers and the right products for them.

    The light at the end of the tunnel is the credible and honest blogger / consumer, creating content not because they get paid but because they are passionate and they care about quality products and great service. Your blog and many others like serve as a valuable resource for consumers and I think the brands that start to recognize integrity is everything will be the ones to win in the long term.

    1. Jane

      thanks Neil! x

  27. I absolutely loved this post Jane! I have a post sitting in my drafts trying to get my feelings out onto the page too. I feel the same way about the blogger community. We are a pretty small blog and love meeting other bloggers, but seeing the bigger bloggers advertorial successes make feel anxious sometimes..

    Emily x
    http://www.emandthem.co.uk

    1. Jane

      I’m genuinely pleased for anyone who feels they are making a success from their blog in financial terms, but less happy with the agents that try to exclude other blogs from campaigns so that they rake in their commission. However, I think that might change somewhat.. I know that many brands have never been less happy with some agents and are preferring to take back the reins of working with bloggers without a middleman. I hope your feelings pass.. and mine!… because we’ve all got something to bring to the party. xx

      1. Sam

        I don’t understand this statement- i.e. what is happening & what the concern is (sorry, bit of an outsider to PR shenanigans!)

        “less happy with the agents that try to exclude other blogs from campaigns so that they rake in their commission.”

        1. Jane

          Well, agents – and there are more and more – sometimes try to ensure that their talent gets the full share of the pie and will suggest that the talent they have may not want to take part in an activity unless it’s with X or Y from the same agency rather than someone outside of their agent roster. I guess it’s their job to do so.

  28. Yenners

    Please keep doing what you’re doing Jane, yours and Temptalia’s are the two blogs that I trust to give an honest opinion about products. I’ve read so many beauty blogs and too many of them gush about all products, which makes me think they’re in it for the free samples and are too scared to be honest in fear of alienating PRs, whereas yours is honest and refreshingly so. Yours is one of the emails I ALWAYS open in an age of information overload (and where I delete three quarters of my inbox without opening the mail).

    I hope this comment helps you understand the impact you have made and continue to make to all of us beauty lovers out there.

    1. Jane

      you’re really kind for taking the time.. it’s very much appreciated x

  29. Yasmine M

    So many things that come into mind. However I think the two main areas that I keep coming back to is 1) when brands/PRs and bloggers/vloggers started cross-pollinating and 2) the consumer perspective.
    I think what we’re seeing now in terms of behaviour from content creators is the fallout from the shift that happened when the advertising industry finally caught up and embraced digital. They’re doing what they should be doing which is forging relationships and controlling the message. It’s what they did in print and it’s what’s happening now. The wild west of the beauty industry is being tamed.
    Why beauty blogging started booming in the first place was because we as consumers had a thirst for the real story behind the glossy ad campaigns-I think sometimes this gets forgotten. We wanted to know what really worked and what didn’t. I think the popularity of your “business end of beauty” posts prove that people are still interested in the behind the scenes. The medium will always change but an unibiased account is what people are craving, myself included.
    I don’t think sponsored reviews are an issue if you have a solid reputation, but that takes time. The problem is when relatively new bloggers/vloggers pop up and all they’re doing is sponsored content, there’s no trust or credibilty. I do think you have to earn your stripes and be really careful at how much you collaborate with brands, if your goal is to be the eyes an ears for other consumers. Otherwise you’re on the other team-and that’s fine but then you’re not who I’m looking for when I want a review on a product.
    I really think things are going to get better. PRs will age like the rest of us and have a better understanding and respect for the dynamics of digital. Independant content creators will have a better sense of their profession, they’ll have precedents and best practices to refer to as time goes by and the industry evolves.
    So Jane, they’ll always be a place for you in the beauty community however you decide to partake. Like so many other readers you are my go-to blog as well as my mum’s and we also discuss your posts 🙂

    1. Jane

      Thanks for such an eloquent and thoughtful comment.. and you are correct on all levels; I think at the beginning we were so new at it we were given (after a bit of a rough start) pretty much free reign.. now the control is being taken back it’s more difficult to be as spontaneous and provoking as perhaps we once were. I don’t like control on any level so I guess it’s natural that I’m feeling the strain of it. x

  30. I want to put my arms around you and hug the life out of you ! I don’t want to write a tome. But caught you tonight on periscope. My lil heart sang to see you wernt a beautiful 20 something. But a beautiful mature honest woman. I have recently started blogging thinking there must be women like me who are still interested in fashion beauty LIFE ! I am 58 so you lovely lady are a spring chicken. I talk to myself on my blogs. Have no comments as yet so can’t relate on the biz side of things. But YOU have a voice that inspires us older birds. Keep flying the flag.
    http://www.thelavenderbarn.blogspot.co.uk

    Big hugz
    Lyn x

    1. Jane

      Lynda, thank you so much! And thanks for joining me on Periscope.. xx

      1. Loving the new medium, well, new to me anyway, keep up the brilliant work, you are an inspiration x

  31. Alexandra

    A very interesting article and comments!

    I launched my own beauty/travel blog about 2.5 years ago (but it has been inactive for quite a few months now). Although it wasn’t that long ago, I have felt that the industry has changed substantially since then. From my perception, it seems to have gone from a culture of everyone being quite new, experimenting together and really learning and supporting each other – a real community – to now being much more competitive … with a proliferation of new bloggers ‘fighting’ for products and site stats, along with brands who are increasingly demanding of bloggers to feature their products and for favourable reviews.

    The feeling that brands were pushing product at you to feature on your blog – like you ‘owe’ them something if you accept an event invite or free product – was quite overwhelming and really put me off. Personally, I love to connect with other bloggers, people, a brand and the ‘behind the scenes’ brand owners or creators, and I would prefer to go and buy a product off the shelf to feature on my blog, as it feels as if the shackles are cut loose.

    I know it’s not all like that, and there are some genuinely amazing people that I have met through my blogging and great brands and brand owners, but I have certainly felt like the community aspect has certainly taken a backseat.

    Although I’m not blogging so much these days, I’ve joined ‘the other side’ and I am in the process of launching my own skincare brand. Although my products have not launched yet, I have been experimenting again with connecting with customers and it’s interesting to see that the most ‘interaction/interest’ that I get from the public is through instragram or sharing images that are lifestyle focused or special behind the scenes style shots. My theory is that this creates much more of a feeling of mutual connection and community, rather than shoving a product down a readers throat and writing a glowing review.

    A lot of thoughts here, but I guess in summary, I think that the relationship that’s formed between people – whether it is between blogger, a blogger and brand, a brand and consumers or a blogger and their readers – is the most important thing, and this seems to have really fallen to the wayside in the last months / years with a lot of brands and blogs. It’s a real shame.

    I read your blog every day (via email) and I do feel that connection that you have with your readers. You write about what you are really thinking, which builds trust within the community that you have formed. You also listen to feedback from your readers and adjust accordingly (like the beauty business articles) which shows that you are there for us, rather than to make a quick quid or get a free product (I am sure you really don’t need any more!!)

    Anyway, some food for thought. It will be interesting to see if the trend comes full circle in the coming months and filters out those players that don’t fit in with building the community that blogs and brands need to stay alive. After all, we are all in this together!

    X

    1. Jane

      Thank you so much for your thoughtful and constructive comments xx

  32. Nataile Brown

    I’m not a blogger just a blog reader, but I have to tell you that, at my age (50+) I want to see women my age wearing and reviewing products. I enjoy some of the younger bloggers posts too if I can sense that they’re being honest or if they have a similar skin tone to mine. (Just because I know the product will look relatively the same on me.) It gets tiring to read posts for products that “tick all the boxes” when I know I’ve read other reviews that weren’t that good. Bottom line is, I don’t purchase a product until I’ve researched it through blog reviews. I don’t have money to lose on products that aren’t going to work or look right on me. So, I thank-you for being a “mature” blogger who’s honest. 🙂

    1. Jane

      thank you so much! xx

  33. olivia

    Honestly, I used to find makeup so exciting, ironically more exciting when there wasn’t social media, just forums. Now with all the major PR of many brands which I haven’t tried because I really have no interest in them due to over hype. I have become a bit numb. Is this cosmetic depression? LOL

    I am assuming we are the same generation and to see the major socializing on various outlets takes personal time which you know is pretty precious at our age. I am sure if I were a teen I would be on every social media site PR-ing this and that because of the major time on my hands.

    Blogging has changed in terms of everyone wants something now. Bloggers/vloggers will step on each other to be where they are. I am not saying all will do that but I have had my fair share of distaste in this blogosphere.

    Being mature and wise is great but when it comes to beauty it becomes this stigma because the world thinks youth is always beautiful. Beauty doesn’t come in a jar, it comes with years of everything from pain to happiness.

    I think this is what blogging is now, it is becoming beautiful because it is past its prime. Sure, youtube and all those social media outlets have up to the minute PR but it is only because it is easy. Easy gets boring, very fast.

    So, sorry this is long Jane. But, what I am trying to say is, like a good classic novel Your blogging is becoming an art which many admire including myself. Blogging is hard because it takes complete paragraphs and sentences!

    Do what you are doing because you wouldn’t have survived this long if you didn’t have the skills!

    xoxo,

    Olivia – a long time admirer

    1. Jane

      Olivia! We have been in this together long enough… always delighted to hear your thoughts. x

  34. Cy

    I was ill most of last week, and upon returning to work (yes this is when I read your blog, shh!) I thought “Oooh there must be so many posts on BBB for me to catch up on!” and that made me smile.

    I don’t think of you as older really, or that your content doesn’t apply to me because I’m younger, I think we can all tell by your love of cute kawai things, temporary tatts & Converse that you’re still young at heart!

    It may be a case of too many cooks have spoiled the broth given how blogging has exploded, anybody can start a blog and post about the same products, what makes a difference is the blogger him/herself and their way of blogging. I keep reading yours because it’s informative, fuss-free, honest, funny, and the content shows that despite being one of the most well known bloggers it has never gone to your head. The fact that you’re questioning whether you’re too old for this game proves it. But the answer is a big fat NO. You are very much relevant, we love you, and I’m sticking two fingers up to the PR people who think otherwise.
    Oh, and I promise I won’t hug you should I ever meet you (even though I’ll want to!) 😉

    1. Jane

      oh bless you.. what a super comment..thank you so much for it. I may, if we meet, allow a small shoulder pat ;-))

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from British Beauty Blogger

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading