Pay Your Interns Rumbles On

Ok, so the Pay Your Interns piece I ran yesterday obviously struck a chord with many of you – there are some very pertinent and frankly, heartbreaking comments on the piece if you’d care to read them. However, I flagged up one publication – The Diary Directory (a beauty industry bible that lists everyone who’s anyone in beauty) in my observation that if such industry vehicles refused to take unpaid internships job adverts, then more companies would struggle to find the sought after gratis graduates. I received back a measured and thoughtful response which I am republishing here – it’s not often those at the top are willing to respond so openly, so I’m happy that Diary did. It’s also interesting however, to see that nobody in the beauty world has come back and commented that they think unpaid internships are wonderful.

Diary’s Comment:

‘It’s a tricky one! Personally, I completely agree with the ranting, and rant about it myself. We have had girls come for interview for (paid) positions at Diary & Diary Directory who have been interning at magazines for, in some cases, up to two years unpaid! It was my understanding that the National Minimum Wage was a legal requirement unless under certain specific circumstances – eg a required temporary work placement (ie a couple of weeks) as part of a relevant course of study.
As to whether it is the responsibility of publications not to advertise internships, we are in a competitive market where customer service is paramount, and if Diary won’t post our paying subscribers’ intern vacancies – someone else will. (I have had a look at Diary Directory’s Job Lots page and currently we have 8 paid vacancies, and 7 internships.)
We often speak to people, not only journalists, but stylists, make-up artists, photographers, illustrators etc, who are suffering because they are finding it increasingly difficult to get paid a fair wage for their work – prospective employers can instead commission a keen, recent graduate, who is only to happy to work for free… for now. Until the bills and other costly realities of life kick in. Perhaps then, when they have the temerity to ask for a wage, they will be replaced by a more recent graduate / someone less financially encumbered!
My own opinion, is that people should not work / be expected to work more than a couple of weeks unpaid, that they should always receive expenses, and, perhaps most importantly, that the job should offer them real and useful experience. Diary used an intern recently (she was American and did two weeks work experience as part of her ‘English Studies’ course which required a summer stay in the UK). Whilst she was here, she was taught to mail merge, how to do some basic html, a bit about databases, and massively improved her phone skills (don’t underestimate them!) A friend of hers on the same course interned at a PR agency (not to be named!) and spent a week dusting, tidying – and varnishing a door.
It is not publications’ responsibility to enforce the NMW law, but that of the companies trying to get free labour. But you have made me think – perhaps Diary will start requesting a guarantee from advertisers that their internships are short-term, with expenses paid, and where real experience is being offered. We won’t be able to police it – but perhaps it’s a start?’


Discover more from British Beauty Blogger

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Have your say

6 responses to “Pay Your Interns Rumbles On”

  1. DINKY

    Bravo to Diary for offering to change their practice when placing their client’s internship advertisements. It may be a small step, but having such an influential organisation not only showing their views on this situation but taking practical steps towards doing something about it, is a massive encouragement.

    Also want to say a huge thanks BBB for voicing your opinion on this! As many other people commented earlier, it means a lot to hear someone so established say these long unpaid internships just aint right.

  2. Just to echo what DINKY says really – so pleased that Diary have taken these comments on board, and are considering reviewing their policies… And great that this issue has been raised in the first place…

  3. Grace London

    That is a really positive piece of feedback, and thank you for raising such an important issue. I know a couple of friends who did internships at PR companies (years ago,) but in each case the ‘free’ period was less than a month. Stringing it out any longer just isn’t right.

  4. Lina

    Brilliant! Well done, BBB. If they atleast pay for expenses, that’s a start. Makes it defintely more widely accessible for everyone, not just the privileged – at least their not out of pocket by working there. Not earning money, but not out of pocket. A small start but massively better than nothing. xx

  5. Anonymous

    AT LONG LAST! There is no other word for free internships than EXPLOITATION! Those who are willing to work hard and prove their worth are in a sense, punished not rewarded.

    Having been to University, interned at many magazines and PR companies (all for free) I was rendered pennyless and depressed. Oh, no support from the government either. Want to do an internship as a means to maybe secure a job? Well, it simply won’t happen. In my opinion that is the essence of actively looking for work. But if you were to stay at home and watch day time tv all week you would be granted job seekers allowance. Crazy.

    If an intern is doing a job PAY THEM!

  6. Reza

    I’m not British, but the same thing happens in the States, and I’m touched by Diary’s response to your comments. The thought of hard-working young adults (or simply adults) emerging into the big, wide world just to find that companies are only ready to use and abuse them is a horrifying one. I’m new to your blog, but I find this conversation quite compelling. Keep asking the hard questions, BBB. It’s not just the answers that are important–it’s changes like this that you can initiate in the world. Brava!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from British Beauty Blogger

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading