The Maybelline Master Ink in Satin is the nearest I think I’ve seen for a vinyl effect liner – it definitely holds a sheen to it, and the Matte Version in indeed a very flat matte black.
The matte version doesn’t look as dense in this swatch, but I don’t think I shook the bottle well enough because I’ve just retested and it’s pitch black. I don’t use these types of liner myself because you need such a steady hand (even my swatch is wobbly) so I’ll have to wait for a glossy pencil version! These haven’t launched on line yet but well worth looking out for in store if you love – and can apply – a super sleek line.
All products are sent to me as samples from brands and agencies unless otherwise stated. Affiliate links may be used. Posts are not affiliate driven.