Hermes Lipstick £62 – Would You?

[unpaid/affiliate] I did a reel on Instagram last week asking whether £62 for a lipstick has gone over the point of what’s acceptable to pay for a make up item. It was genuinely so interesting to get the responses – mostly people said they wouldn’t be prepared to pay that, a few people said they’d already bought some and others said they’d pay that amount for skin care but not for make up.

Hermes Lipstick

The thing is, as a luxury brand, Hermes would never produce a make up item that wasn’t in line, price wise, with their brand. Everything at Hermes is priced for full pockets and it’s a heritage brand that has carved its own place in the luxury market. Relatively speaking, £62, is a bit of a snip for that coach & horse logo that echoes their roots as saddle makers.

Hermes Lipstick

Luxury brands are a breed apart – they’re not interested really in your ‘average’ customer – they’re interested in a clientele for whom price is not even a thought. There’s the reverse psychology aspect of making things so unattainable they become completely desirable but this is a brand that works tightly within the luxury space – they’re so sure of the customer they want that they don’t need to pay any attention to those they don’t. It’s arrogant but they are perfectly able to do it. The reverse would be that Primark isn’t catering to the wealthy, they don’t need them or court them – it’s the same, but the other way around. Interesting though that Chanel doesn’t out-price what is a very lucrative corner of the market and nor does Dior. They keep their beauty products at affordable luxury prices – desirable and just attainable while ensuring their fashion arm stays at the top end.

Hermes Lipstick

Personally, I love the packaging. I always thought that Hermes should do one limited edition ‘perfect red’ lipstick in their signature orange coating and release a new limited shade each season. As it happens, one of the two shades I have here is limited editions- and £66!

Hermes Lipstick

This is Rouge Cinabre in a matte finish – I expected it to look much more brickish when on but actually, I rather like it. For a matte, it’s exceptionally smooth and non-drying. I usually get a feeling of having to remove mattes if I wear for any length of time – it’s just not the texture for me – but I didn’t get that sense of dryness at all with this. And, to be honest, I’d expect it to be a next level formula. I’ve looked through the ingredient list and it doesn’t seem to be anything particularly special but you can’t, from reading the list, tell what quality the ingredients are.

Hermes Lipstick

This is Rouge H (£62) in a satin finish – it’s way too deep a shade for me to naturally pick although once on, I was surprised to actually quite like it. The upshot is that if they feel special to you (and they are rather special – heritage, design, quality) then they’re probably ‘worth’ every penny. I try not to make assumptions about BBB readers’ budgets – I think like all cross-sections there will be a variety – but feel that we’d all want to know how a £66 lipstick justifies itself. Well, it doesn’t. It doesn’t have to, and that’s how the luxury market survives I guess.

Hermes Lipstick

On the bottom, Rouge Cinabre, up top, Rouge H. However, at Selfridges, rather than the Hermes site, both are £62 which is inexplicable and a poor attention to detail from a brand that prides itself on such things. They’re HERE. They’re all refillable and refills are £33.

 

Non-affiliate HERE. 


Discover more from British Beauty Blogger

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Have your say

22 responses to “Hermes Lipstick £62 – Would You?”

  1. Chrissie

    Well said Jane about the pricing and target market and customer. On my budget I wouldn’t pay £62 + for a lipstick, but I will for good skincare if needed as a treat. It’s there if you wish to have it, no one is under pressure to purchase these items. I would also expect samples, lovely packaging and so on and great service in store.
    Beauty items aren’t essentials per se but in terms of how I roll and liking how I look with mascara, foundation etc they certainly help maintain my mojo, especially with my super winter pallor! So I will continue to be spending on anything from MUA to Chanel.
    If I was going to be really splurge on a lipstick (and I keep playing around with this on their website) I’d go to Carolina Herrera where you can choose the formula, the case, have an animal charm or 3 including an initial and accessorise it up.
    And yes both colours look absolutely terrific on you! Happy Monday xxx

    1. Jane Cunningham

      Thanks Chrissie! I love the Herrera charms – just bringing an unexpected element to the whole thing. I always feel its not up to me to make a judgement on other people’s budget but I am going to counterbalance soon with some nicely priced lip products as well. And you’re right – they’re not compulsory purchasing – it’s choice and budget and how certain brands speak to your taste levels.

  2. Helen

    Hmm … Well, I’ve just spend £62 on Westman Atelier foundation but I’ll wear it every day, and top end foundation does seem to me to have a skincare element to it. If I was going to spend this much on a lipstick I’d rather have the beautiful Dries Van Noten case you posted about recently – so tempting!

    1. Jane Cunningham

      I hear you – Dries Van Noten are rather beautiful! I guess its about which brands resonate with you and I thought it was very interesting that few turned a hair at the price for skin care but baulked at it for lipstick.

  3. Ann

    Back in the day Paloma Picasso, Mon Rouge was always marketed at a higher price point. I could never quite bring myself to spend that much money on a lipsrick. Having said that, they do look lovely and it’s still less than the price of two Chanel or Dior ones.

    1. Jane Cunningham

      You’re making it sound positively reasonable there, Ann :-)))))))))

    2. Mandy Webb

      I had that lipstick, and it was the ‘perfect’ red. Wish I could buy another one now.

      1. Jane Cunningham

        It’s a much brighter red than it appears in the bullet – I thought it would be more bricky.

        1. Mandy Webb

          Sorry, meant the Paloma Picasso red! Loved it!

          1. Jane Cunningham

            Oh I see – how lovely 🙂

  4. Anna van Munster

    Wow, how interesting that on you the matt Cinabre looks more satin than the H! (or it’s a joke of a camera?) I love both colors… Cannot say that color blocking of design speaks much to me though.. In this case Dries van Noten, Carolina Herrera, Byredo or (awwwwh, drooling on that for quite some time) By Killian lure me into them stronger. Said that, 62 pounds (or nearly 70 Euro) is rather far stretch for me for a lipstick. Having jolly family of four Lisa Eldridge ones (+2 Givenchy) all about 30-35 Euro each (and previously Chanel, Dior and Lancome ones) it’s around there where I draw the line for lipstick price for me… Skincare is another area – there I can stretch further *looks at collection of ReFa massagers and the last Demarrer TNA toner* But… in case of some happy lottery winning some splurge on unreasonably priced luxury makeup can be expected *blushing*. 🙂

    1. Jane Cunningham

      Yes indeed, a lottery win would be most welcome! I think perhaps a trick of the light but for a matte, it’s remarkably kind to the lips. It’s each to their own isn’t? For some a bottle of fine wine can cost the same and that’s gone in a flash and for others it’s off the scale of reasonableness to spend so much on a lipstick, whether its budgetary restrictions or common sense restrictions!

  5. Debbie

    I loved the look of these- and I love lipstick more than any other beauty item- so I followed the link to Selfridges and discovered that the case is also refillable (at least for some of the colours) – refills are £33, which is much more in line with other brands for a lipstick. So now the question is – is the case worth £29?!

    1. Jane Cunningham

      Gosh, thank you so much for reminding me – I meant to put that in and will do so now!

  6. Donna

    For a lipstick, no. Now a foundation, yes I would pay that. The initial outlay for the Hermes case still not worth it.

    1. Jane Cunningham

      Exactly what Instagram said – no for a lipstick but for skin care & base, yes.

  7. Morag

    I love the bottom colour on you.

    Hmmmm if I was sure this was ‘the one’ I know I’d buy it. (Says quietly) Instead I’m experimenting with brands etc.

    1. Jane Cunningham

      It’s maybe a bit easier knowing the refills are £33 (still expensive) – the £62 or £66 outlay is just the once.

  8. Jane

    It rankles for the same reason so much rankles – terrible wealth inequality in the world means that little luxuries like this feel a little too “let them eat cake” when so many are having to go without.

    That said I have looked and looked and looked at this and if there’s a perfect lipstick color and perfect case color, yes. But it wouldn’t be casual and I’d be refilling it when it ran out.

    1. Jane Cunningham

      Jane I hear 100% what you are saying – beauty is across the board ridiculously priced but people pay it so it still flourishes. However, my thought is always that you just don’t know what other people’s money goes on – for all we know people are buying expensive lipstick AND addressing inequality by donating to charities or helping in some other way. I try to cover products with a neutral attitude to the money because your income isn’t really any of my business but there are some things that make me wince for sure 🙂

  9. Thank you for this well written article on the pricing differences between Hermès and other high end brands like Chanel and Dior. As a lover of lipstick and perfume I am usually prepared to pay more for either of them now and then, esp. as I consider it my “job” for my own blog, hah (but really it’s just a justification to spend on what I love). After testing countless lipsticks in all price ranges I know that the price point does not always match the quality, but that the ambition usually is there at least.

    But then you see these series that are just priced so highly on purpose to be unattainable, in both the lipstick and the perfume world. It irks me because it makes it clear that these are not created for us who value quality but for those who want to be exclusive. So as much as I would love to have a Hermès lipstick in my quest to try all lipsticks in the world I will pass on it, although the Rouge H looks like an AMAZING colour (and great on you!). In abstaining, it helps that you reviewed them so I at least know what they are about from someone I trust!

    1. Jane Cunningham

      Thanks Jenny 🙂 I think you’ve it the nail on the head there about it being a deliberate exclusion strategy whhich never feels nice for any consumer. But, it’s so common – I’m excluded from several brands PR wise – Gucci (not approved for send outs), Hermes (again not approved), Jones Road (which is just ironic since I’ve supported Bobbi from the very get-go well before she was bought by ELC and met her several times) and several others but they can’t stop me buying the products and saying what I think. So, sometimes I do just to be a pain in the butt for them and to give a more complete picture for readers – I honestly think they can’t get past the fact that I’m writing for readers and not as free marketing for them. I’ve got good search on Google so invariably my reviews hit page 1 or 2 so they might as well. With the reader-first mandate I still have to be as fair as I can even if I begrudge every single word sometimes!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from British Beauty Blogger

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading